Substance Use

The Problem With Sober Living Homes

serenity lane sign

Table of Contents

Get Help Now

check insurance
Check your insurance by using our Online Form
call us
Talk to someone now.
Call (855) 430-9439

Finding the courage to seek help for your addiction is challenging. The last thing you want to do is choose a treatment program that cannot help you achieve and maintain a drug-free life. While substance use disorders can be treated in a variety of ways, the factors of success go beyond your living environment.

Before you or your loved one seek support for substance abuse in a sober living house, here’s what you need to know.

Call us
Ready to get help?
(855) 430-9439
Why call us? Why call us

What is a Sober Living Home?

Sober-living homes are sometimes referred to as halfway houses. A halfway house is a transitional home for those who have just completed an addiction treatment program but aren’t ready to leave alone. Halfway houses provide curfews and a support system to help people during that sensitive in-between period as they get used to living sober independently. In other words, halfway houses can be an invaluable part of the recovery process. (1)

However, not all sober living homes have the same rules. For instance, it is not always a requirement for someone entering a sober living home to have completed an addiction treatment program. Instead, you’ll likely be expected to find and attend outpatient services independently.

It’s important to understand that while sober living homes aim to provide a secure and budget-friendly community living environment, they might not offer the comprehensive support essential for your recovery. They often lack personalized, one-on-one assistance.

Peer support within a sober living home may not always be conducive to recovery, especially if fellow residents are not receiving the necessary help they require. These circumstances can elevate the risk of relapse for individuals residing in a sober living home. It’s essential to consider these factors when evaluating your options for recovery. (2)

Sober Living House vs. Addiction Treatment Center

When seeking help for addiction recovery, individuals often choose between sober living houses and addiction treatment centers. Each option offers unique features and plays a distinct role in the recovery process.

Sober Living Houses

  1. Transitional Living: Sober living houses primarily serve as transitional recovery residences for individuals who have completed a formal addiction treatment program. They offer a needed bridge and many protections between the structured treatment environment and returning to independent living or living with family members.
  2. Peer Support and Accountability: One of the central strengths of sober living houses is the strong sense of peer support and accountability. Residents in these houses share a common goal – maintaining sobriety – and often find strength in their collective commitment. (3)
  3. Autonomy and Responsibility: Residents in sober living homes have more autonomy than treatment centers. They are encouraged to take on responsibilities such as finding employment, managing household chores, and contributing to the house’s overall upkeep. This fosters a sense of personal responsibility.
  4. Oversight by Non-Professional Staff: Sober living homes are usually overseen by non-professional staff members who enforce house rules, ensure the safety and well-being of residents, and create a supportive environment for recovery.
  5. Less Structured Environment: In sober living houses, residents can enjoy a less structured and more relaxed environment compared to the controlled setting of addiction treatment centers.

Addiction Treatment Centers

  1. Comprehensive Treatment Programs: Addiction treatment centers provide intensive and evidence-based treatment programs designed to address the root causes of drug abuse, drug addiction, or alcohol abuse. They offer a wide range of therapeutic services, providing holistic care.
  2. Professional Staff: These centers are staffed with medical professionals, therapists, and addiction specialists who design and oversee personalized treatment plans and offer health services. The involvement of professionals ensures a high standard of care and individualized attention.
  3. Medical Detoxification: Many addiction treatment centers offer medical detoxification to ensure the safe and supervised withdrawal from drugs or alcohol. This is particularly important for individuals with severe substance dependencies. (4)
  4. Structured Environment: Treatment centers provide a highly structured and controlled environment. This controlled setting aims to minimize triggers and distractions, creating a safe space for recovery and healing.
  5. Variety of Therapies: In addiction treatment centers, individuals can access various therapeutic modalities, including individual counseling, group therapy, and holistic approaches that encompass mental, emotional, and physical well-being. This diverse range of therapies addresses addiction comprehensively.

Challenges and Considerations with Sober Living Homes

The primary issues with sober living homes revolve around the lack of structured treatment services. (5) A supportive environment isn’t enough to recover from addiction. True recovery programs will offer one-on-one assistance from a healthcare provider and various counseling and therapy programs.

Here are some more details on the challenges that these sober living homes can bring:

Lack of Structured Treatment Service

Sober living homes are often criticized for lacking structured support and formal addiction treatment programs. While they offer a supportive environment for residents, they do not typically provide the comprehensive services necessary for addiction recovery. (5)

The absence of structured treatment can be a significant drawback, as many individuals require a more structured approach to address complex addiction issues.

Varied House Rules and Relapse Risks

The house rules within sober living homes can vary significantly from place to place. This lack of standardization can lead to inconsistencies in support and recovery-focused measures.

Some homes may have more lenient rules, while others may have stricter regulations. These variations can present challenges for individuals seeking consistency and a clear path to recovery. Without well-defined guidelines, residents may struggle to maintain their sobriety and manage their risk of relapse effectively.

However, if residents violate these rules, the consequences may vary significantly depending on the house. In some cases, violating house rules could lead to eviction from the home without any guidance or assistance for seeking treatment. 

This consequence may be detrimental to residents who require structured support and interventions to address their addiction effectively.

Limitations of Informal Support Groups

Sober living homes commonly rely on informal support groups for peer assistance and accountability. While these groups can be valuable, especially for building a sense of community and shared goals, they are not a comprehensive solution.

Formal addiction treatment often requires a multifaceted approach that includes individual counseling, group therapy, and evidence-based programs. Reliance solely on informal support groups may leave some residents without the essential therapeutic elements necessary for their recovery journey.

Potential for Negative Peer Influence

Sober living houses foster a sense of community among residents, which can be both an advantage and a challenge. While positive peer influence can provide essential support, the potential for negative peer influence also exists.

If some residents do not fully commit to their recovery or have lapses in sobriety, it can influence others negatively. This dynamic can hinder recovery, as residents may be exposed to triggers or behaviors that counteract their sobriety goals.

Ultimately, a sober living home might be viable if you need a safe, affordable place to live while enrolling in an intensive outpatient treatment program. However, a sober living home shouldn’t be your first stop if you’re looking for addiction treatment.

Weighing the Pros and Cons: Are There Any Benefits?

Sober living homes can be a safe and supportive housing option when participating in an outpatient addiction treatment program, ensuring that individuals have a stable and drug-free environment to aid their recovery.

After completing an inpatient recovery program, individuals often need a place to stay before transitioning to independent living. Sober living homes can offer a transitional space that fosters continued recovery.

It’s important to note that sober living homes and halfway houses may have differing policies. To enhance the effectiveness of recovery housing, it is advisable to seek out facilities where residents are required to participate in recovery efforts actively or have already completed an inpatient program.

The benefits are notable in such settings:

  • Reduced Risk: Well-structured and managed sober living homes that emphasize active engagement in the recovery process reduce the chances of substance misuse within the environment.
  • Supportive Environment: A community of individuals actively working toward recovery fosters a positive and supportive atmosphere, which can be further enhanced through a house manager, peer support, and group counseling.
  • Structured Rules: While top-rated sober living homes may enforce strict rules, including curfews, these regulations can help individuals focus on their recovery journey. Advancing through the recovery program often leads to additional privileges, easing the transition to independent living.
  • Accountability: Sober homes encourage personal responsibility, requiring residents to adhere to house rules and actively participate in recovery programs, promoting accountability and progress.
  • Peer Support: Sharing the journey with others in similar circumstances provides residents with peer support, understanding, and camaraderie, fostering a sense of belonging and motivation.
  • Gradual Transition: These homes offer a step-by-step transition from intensive inpatient care to independent living, ensuring that individuals are well-prepared for life in recovery

What Does Addiction Treatment Look Like?

Regardless of your chosen program, various essential services can be integrated into your customized treatment plan:

  • Behavioral Health Care: Helps you comprehend addiction’s root causes and triggers. (6)
  • Mental Health Care: Provides support for coping with psychological symptoms during recovery.
  • Treatment for Co-occurring Disorders: Addresses conditions such as PTSD, depression, or anxiety alongside addiction. (7)(8)
  • Counseling: Includes individual and group sessions, including family therapy.
  • Occupational Therapy: Facilitates a smoother transition into a fulfilling, sober life.

Your healthcare provider will collaborate with you to identify and structure the most suitable services to meet your needs. As you progress in your treatment journey, the frequency of these services may be reduced to prepare you for independent living.

How to Structure Your Treatment Program

There is no one-size-fits-all approach for recovering from drug and alcohol use. However, established best practices have been shown to reduce the unpleasant symptoms of withdrawal, shorten the recovery time frame, and ensure long-term success.

If you’re recovering from alcohol addiction, 12-step meetings might be the first program that comes to mind. However, they’re far from your only option. (9) You may go through the initial detox period at an inpatient facility, which can last up to two weeks. From there, you may enroll in a residential treatment center, sober living residences, or an outpatient program.

Here’s a structured breakdown:

  1. Initial Detoxification Phase: Recovery from alcohol addiction often begins with an initial detox period lasting up to two weeks. This phase can be effectively managed at an inpatient facility. The focus here is on medical supervision, safety, and stabilization during the early stages of withdrawal. (10)
  2. Inpatient and Residential Treatment: After detox, individuals have several choices. Residential treatment centers, sometimes called “rehab centers,” provide round-the-clock care to reduce drug use and improve mental health. Specialists and healthcare professionals staff them. They offer a comprehensive range of services within the facility, reducing the need to travel for treatment.
  3. Outpatient Programs: Outpatient programs are an option for those seeking more flexibility. These programs allow individuals to reside outside the treatment facility while attending sessions. In outpatient settings, drug testing is typically required to monitor progress and adherence to treatment goals.
  4. Sober Homes: Sober living homes serve as supportive, drug-free living environments for individuals in recovery. These are particularly relevant when transitioning from inpatient or outpatient programs to independent living. Residents often demonstrate commitment to sobriety by adhering to house rules and regularly attending support meetings for follow-up.

To maximize the chances of long-term success in overcoming addiction, it’s crucial to explore the full spectrum of available services and consider individual needs. While a safe living environment is vital, additional treatment services are central in helping individuals navigate detox and withdrawal and ultimately attain a sober life.

The bottom line is that recovery housing may be a part of your treatment program, but it will never be the solution.

Before enrolling in a sober living home, hoping that separating yourself from drugs will cure the problem, you should educate yourself on your options. The reality is that having a safe place to sleep is important, but you will also need additional services to help you get through the initial detox and withdrawal process and get on your feet to achieve a sober life.

How to Maximize the Benefits of a Sober Living Home

Sober living homes serve as valuable resources in the recovery journey, offering a stable, drug-free environment. Strategically integrating them into one’s recovery program is essential to leverage their advantages fully. 

Below are some ways to maximize the benefits of a sober living home.

  1. Alignment with Treatment Plan: Ensure that your choice of a sober living home aligns with your overall recovery strategy. Whether transitioning from inpatient care or seeking support while attending outpatient programs, the sober living home should complement your treatment goals.
  2. Structured Living: Embrace the structure of the sober living home, as it can bridge formal treatment and independent living. Adhering to house rules and expectations supports your commitment to sobriety.
  3. Regular Attendance: Actively participate in house meetings, peer support sessions, and any counseling or therapy services offered at home. Regular attendance reinforces accountability and helps build a supportive network.
  4. Continued Treatment Services: Recognize that addiction recovery requires an ongoing process. No matter what type of program you choose, various services can be incorporated into your treatment plan. These may include:
    • Behavioral health care to understand the causes and triggers of addiction.
    • Mental health care to address psychological symptoms during recovery.
    • Treatment for co-occurring disorders like PTSD, depression, or anxiety.
    • Individual and group counseling, including family sessions.
    • Occupational therapy to facilitate a successful transition to a fulfilling sober life. Work closely with your healthcare provider to determine what’s best.  As you progress in your treatment, the frequency of services you receive each week may decrease as you prepare for independent living.
  5. Continued Support Post-Recovery: Recovery is an ongoing journey. Discuss with your healthcare provider how they plan to support you after completing your inpatient or outpatient program. This may include access to texting support, helplines, and involvement in supportive social networks. A robust post-recovery support plan enhances your chances of maintaining a drug-free life.

How We Can Help With Your Recovery Process

Coming to terms with all the treatment options available can be difficult. That’s why it’s important to contact a facility that can provide reliable information about the available programs.

At Zinnia Health, we strive to offer every individual the most information possible about addiction recovery so that they can make an informed decision.

Some of the options we can help you explore include:

  • Customized inpatient and outpatient treatment plans
  • Support for mental illness and disabilities
  • Nearby recovery housing to help you through the transition

Are you looking for more information about addiction recovery? Speak to the experienced recovery specialists at Zinnia Health. We believe in offering caring, personalized support in a judgment-free environment. Plus, our helpline is open 24/7. Just dial (855) 430-9439 to get started.


Call us
Ready to get help?
(855) 430-9439
Why call us? Why call us